Originally written by Tom Wickenden of Betashares, 3rd March 2022
Commodities: Does the Russia/Ukraine Conflict Reinforce the Bull Case?
History tells us that geopolitics rarely matters for markets, except when it does, and then it’s the only thing that matters. The announcements from Western officials over the weekend were significant and historic, and countered the prevailing belief among analysts that the West wouldn’t risk short-term economic pain in order to damage the Russian war effort.
The medium-term implications of an escalation in military activity are a potential increase in fiscal spending from major powers and with it a further inflationary impulse. However, the footprint the region has in the global commodities markets and the implications of major disruption to energy and agricultural production and supply could reinforce the existing case for commodities markets broadly.
The Bull Case for Commodities
Prior to the outbreak of war in Ukraine, the bull case for commodities rested not on geopolitical risk, but on existing supply constraints and Covid-induced policy responses that have increased commodity demand.
- Commodities broadly are considered one of the best inflation hedges amongst conventional assets and have historically tended to decorrelate from traditional assets, especially longer-duration ones, during hiking cycles.
- Demand for commodities remains strong and is now above pre-pandemic levels, with China having recently restarted stimulus in response to weak data and the European fiscal recovery fund now being spent.
- Inventories are extremely tight, the lowest since 1990,1 with minimal spare production capacity. The ability for supply to respond is limited, due to a lack of capital investment across commodity sectors.
- The slow supply response is arguably structural not cyclical. Amongst other factors, the rise of ESG considerations has limited the availability of capital for capex investment needed to increase supply capacity to meet future demand. It has also likely raised the price level required to attract new investment. This is particularly the case in US shale, which has effectively placed a ceiling on the oil price over the last decade.
Ukraine/Russia – Commodity supply shock
The probability of a global food crisis and a potentially longer bull market in soft commodities, which have already seen a spike in prices, has arguably increased due to Ukraine and Russia’s footprint in agricultural production. Together, Russia and Ukraine represent more than 25% of global wheat exports, while Ukraine alone accounts for almost 15% of global corn exports. Unlike energy, where there remains some, albeit limited, ability for a supply response, there simply isn’t the ability for agricultural supply to ramp up if Europe’s breadbasket is removed from the map (Ukraine’s planting season is weeks away from commencing). Particularly if key shipping zones for agricultural commodities (i.e. the Black Sea) become flashpoints. Thus, any ongoing war-related disruptions to supply could ultimately drive up already high world food prices – which in turn could boost profits for producers.
Source: RBC Capital Markets
The BetaShares Global Agriculture Companies ETF – Currency Hedged (ASX: FOOD) provides exposure to a globally diversified portfolio of the largest 60 companies involved in agriculture and farming, with agriculture companies historically having been highly correlated to broad commodities and arguably one of the better investible proxies to broad commodity prices. The chart below demonstrates this correlation. FOOD also has an investment case as an inflation play, should the current situation lead to central banks tolerating above-target inflation expectations for a while longer.
FOOD vs S&P GSCI Light Energy Index (broad commodity futures index)
Source: Bloomberg. Past performance is not an indicator of future performance.
Beyond soft commodities, Crude prices have now broken $100 per barrel for the first time since 2014. While there are yet to be direct sanctions on Russian commodities, the hurdles that restrictions on Russian access to the SWIFT international payment system have created are already exacerbating the current supply shock. For oil, Goldman Sachs, estimates that this represents $110/bbl to $120/bbl short term price upside. With Russia exporting about 7.3 million barrels a day of seaborne crude oil and petroleum products, which is now shut. Tuesday’s announcement by the IEA that they will be releasing 60mb of emergency oil reserves covers only a third of a one-month disruption to Russian seaborne oil. The only other potential short term supply response available would be from OPEC, which would come at the expense of a ‘complete depletion’ of the global oil market’s spare capacity, potentially pushing prices further higher.2
Though we would note the stock specific risks and need for diversification when investing in some global equities in the current environment, some of which may have exposure to Russian assets, the BetaShares Global Energy Companies ETF – Currency Hedged (ASX: FUEL) provides exposure to the largest 60 global energy companies (excluding companies listed in Australia). This includes a high concentration to energy ‘supermajors’ including Exxon Mobil (8.1%), Chevron (7.8%), Total S.E. (7.2%) and Royal Dutch Shell (5.6%) (as at 31 December). Exposure to the price of crude oil futures can be accessed through the BetaShares Crude Oil ETF (ASX: OOO). We would note that the futures curve is currently in backwardation and not in contango, and when investing in futures-based products we advise investors to monitor the structure of the forward curve. For those who prefer regional exposure, the BetaShares FTSE 100 ETF (ASX: F100) provides a more meaningful exposure to the energy sector relative to other developed market indices.
BetaShares Global Agriculture Companies ETF – Currency Hedged (ASX: FOOD)
- Factsheet
- Research Report
- Product Summary to assist with SOAs
- Target Market Determination
- Product Disclosure Statement
Investment risks include:
- OOO: market risk, commodity volatility risk, roll risk and derivatives risk market risk, country risk and currency hedging risk.
- FUEL: market risk, international investment risk, oil and gas sector risk and concentration risk.
- FOOD: market risk, international investment risk, agriculture sector risk and concentration risk.
For more information on risks and other features of these Funds, please see the respective Product Disclosure Statement.
xcvgv
This document has been provided to you for your general information and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation and needs and must not be relied upon by you as personal financial product advice that has been provided to you by iInvest. If you require advice regarding any aspect of the information and statements of opinion set out in this document, particularly as to whether you should base an investment decision upon the information or statements of opinion set out in this document, please contact your financial adviser.
Distribution
The material contained in this communication is prepared for the exclusive use of clients of iInvest. iInvest is an Authorised Representative (#431611) of Zodiac Securities Pty Ltd (ABN 76142982554) (AFSL #398350).
The information contained herein is confidential and may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, confidentiality is not lost nor privilege waived by your receipt of it. Please delete and destroy all copies. You should not use, copy, disclose or distribute this information without the express written authority of iInvest.
Disclaimer & Disclosure
iInvest, its related companies, officers, employees and agents may have a relevant interest in some of the securities mentioned but those holdings are not material unless disclosed in this communication. These holdings (or absence of holdings) may change at any time after publication of this communication, without notice.
iInvest, its related companies, officers, employees and agents may earn income, fees, brokerage or commissions or other benefits as a result of recommendations, dealing or transactions in the securities mentioned in this communication. These interests do not influence iInvest in giving the general advice contained in this communication. iInvest, its related companies, officers, employees and agents may trade in financial products which is contrary to the recommendations given in this communication.
You should not act on any recommendation made in this document without first consulting your investment adviser in order to ascertain whether the recommendation (if any) is appropriate, having regard to your investment objectives, financial situation and particular needs. Nothing in this communication shall be construed as a solicitation to buy or sell a financial product, or to engage in or refrain from engaging in any transaction. We cannot guarantee that the integrity of this communication has been maintained, is free from errors, omissions, misstatements, virus interception or interference.
Copyright © iInvest Securities, All rights reserved.
